The Holster Store Reviews

The Holster Store has an overall rating of 4.3 based on 19 reviews. Customer feedback on The Holster Store is mixed.

4.3/5.0

19 reviews

5 Stars

14

4 Stars

1

3 Stars

0

2 Stars

4

1 Star

0

All The Holster Store Reviews (19)
MichaelBailey
May 29, 2026
"Pretty comfy once I got used to it"
I wore it for a full day, it felt good overall. It did take me about a day to get used to the feel, but after that it was comfortable enough to keep on without really thinking about it.
GerardoCooper
May 27, 2026
"Nice holster, but takes a bit of work"
The holster is really well made. The stitching looks clean and the leather feels solid, not cheap or rushed at all. My pistol fits in it good, though I did have to mess with it a bit to get it sitting how I wanted, which was kind of annoying. Still, you can tell someone actually took their time making it.
hello_william375
May 19, 2026
"I ordered from theholsterstore.net and, to..."
I ordered from theholsterstore.net and, to be fair, I wasn’t expecting anything unusually fast. But the shipping was quicker than I figured it would be, and the tracking updated like it should. I think it only took a couple days before it was at my door. Everything went smoothly, no complaints from me
andreabrown0785
May 18, 2026
"Ordering felt like a hassle"
I ordered from theholsterstore.net the whole process was more annoying than I expected. The site felt clunky, pages were loading slowly, and checkout kept making me re-enter information. At one point I started worrying I was going to lose my order or get charged without it actually going through.
The holster itself might end up being totally fine, but the ordering experience definitely needs some work. I didn’t get a confirmation right away either, so I was left wondering if I’d just wasted time or money. Not the worst site I’ve used, but I’d be hesitant to order again unless they make checkout smoother.
dorisjones0487
May 10, 2026
"Hid better than I was expecting"
I was surprised how well it hides under shirts. I thought it will show more, but it barely did, so I’m happy with it.
john2000
May 07, 2026
"Fits my pistol just right"
Fit my pistol really well, no wiggle or anything. Feels nice and secure, so im happy with it
GeraldineFletcher
April 28, 2026
"Nice to get the right order for once"
My order showed up exactly how I placed it, the right holster, right size, and right color. that should be the bare minimum, but after dealing with enough mix-ups and customer service back-and-forth from other places, I really appreciated not having to chase anything down. Simple, easy, and I’d order again.
martharojas0451
April 28, 2026
"I got my order from theholsterstore.net the packaging..."
I got my order from theholsterstore.net the packaging was really, really good. Nothing was loose, nothing looked beat up, and it opened up easily too. It’s a small thing, sure, but I really appreciate when an order shows up clean and done right
AndreaRobinson
April 27, 2026
"I had a little trouble figuring..."
I had a little trouble figuring out which holster would actually fit my model, so I sent customer service a message. They got back to me quickly and didn’t make it a whole thing, which I appreciated.
After that, the order went through fine, and the follow-up was nice too. It just felt like real people on the other end helping me out, and that makes a difference
PERRY
March 30, 2026
"Needed a short break-in period"
When I first put them on, they felt stiff, so I wasn’t totally sure at first. After wearing them for a couple days, though, they loosened up and started fitting really well. Now they feel comfortable and fit great.
COOKE
March 02, 2026
"I wanted to like it, but it didn’t really last"
I bought a holster from theholsterstore.net and at first I felt good about it. The fit seemed fine and I was hoping it would be something I could rely on. After a few weeks, though, the stitching started loosening up, and the holster itself seemed to soften to the point where it didn’t feel as secure anymore. Maybe I just happened to get one that wasn’t made quite right, but I was definitely expecting it to hold up longer. It’s not completely useless, but I wouldn’t say it gave me much confidence in terms of durability.
BethWoodlock_64
February 21, 2026
"Feels a bit cheap, haha"
The holster fit was fine overall, but the hardware just didn’t feel that great to me. The clip feels kind of flimsy, and one of the screws started loosening up after only a few days. I was expecting a little better for the price, haha. It’s not awful, but I’d say it was disappointing.
william-Riseden
February 08, 2026
"Solid holster for the price"
I wasn’t looking to spend a bunch, so this one seemed like a good deal to me. I was surprised by how well it fit and how sturdy it feels for the cost. Shipping was straightforward with no problems. For what I needed, I’m happy with it overall.
hello_nathanial064
February 05, 2026
"Showed up right when they said it would"
It came on the exact day they said it would, so no complaints. Delivered as expected, right on time.
hello_adam546
January 27, 2026
"I expected the return to be a..."
I expected the return to be a whole thing because returns are always a pain everywhere, but this was actually super easy. No hassle, no back and forth, just a smooth exchange.
Joan_kull01
January 15, 2026
"Solid holster, no unnecessary fuss"
The leather feels nice and thick, and the stitching looks clean and strong. It’s a simple, solid holster without any unnecessary extras...
JohnSanders_82
December 31, 2025
"I usually stick with my go-to holster brand..."
I usually stick with my go-to holster brand, so I wasn’t really planning to browse much, but the selection here was solid. There were lots of choices, and I found the one I needed way faster than expected. Kind of felt like I was cheating on my usual brand, but I can’t complain.
GladysBritton_22
December 25, 2025
"I was hoping it would hold up..."
I was hoping it would hold up better, but the gun started feeling loose after around a week of use. It just didn’t have the retention I expected
hello_michael686
December 25, 2025
"The leather feels thick but still..."
The leather feels thick but still soft, which is sweet. Way better than I expected for something I’m carrying around every day. Definitely feels legit.
Have a question about The Holster Store?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.